Sell or keep it as a rental?
Compare selling your California home now with keeping it and renting it out: monthly cash flow, and what you could have after the years you choose.
How to think about it
Keeping a home you already own can be one of the easiest ways to become an investor, especially if you have a low-rate mortgage. Selling gives you cash now and no landlord work. The right answer comes down to a few numbers.
- Cash flow: rent minus your payment, taxes, insurance, HOA, repairs, vacancy and management.
- Equity growth: each payment lowers the loan, and the home may gain value.
- The other path: cash from a sale could fund your next home or earn a return elsewhere.
- Taxes: the home sale exclusion depends on living there 2 of the last 5 years, so timing matters. See IRS Topic 701.
Keeping it and buying again?
Lenders can often count rent from your old home as income. Check the numbers with our rental cash flow calculator, or see what you would net from a sale with the seller net proceeds calculator.
Estimate only, not tax, legal or investment advice. Taxes on a sale are not included. Rent grows 3% a year and taxes, insurance and HOA 2% a year in this estimate.
Questions
Is it better to sell my house or rent it out?
It depends on the rent compared with your payment and costs, how much the home may gain in value, and what you would do with the cash from a sale. The calculator compares your total wealth both ways over the years you choose.
What happens to the home sale tax break if I rent it out?
Under IRS rules you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 married filing jointly) if you owned and lived in the home for 2 of the 5 years before the sale. Rent it out for more than 3 years and you can lose that break. Depreciation taken while it was a rental is taxed when you sell. Ask a tax professional.
Can I keep my low-rate mortgage if I rent the house out?
Usually yes. Most loans require you to live in the home at first, typically for 12 months, but you can rent it out after that. Tell your insurance company so the policy covers a rental.
How do I buy my next home if my equity is tied up in this one?
A HELOC on the current home, or a cash-out refinance before you move out, can fund the next down payment. Lenders may count most of the new rent as income. We shop 130+ lenders with one soft credit pull.
What’s your home worth today?
Your value sets how much you can refinance or take out. See recent sales near you, plus where your value could go over 10 years. Free, no credit check.
Selling, buying next, or keeping it
One application.
One soft pull.
130+ lenders.
Apply now, let our Loan Coach show you the loans that fit, or turn on Rate Watch.
